Why Most Marketing Feels Manipulative Instead of Magnetic

Alexander Ford

Published: 12 February 2025

In our last post, we explored why most marketing is broken…

How focusing on the “promised land” of more money, viral posts, and unqualified prospects creates resistance instead of results.

Think about someone with chronic back pain.

They know exactly what would help them…

Physical therapy, better posture, strength training….

Their Facebook feed is full of solutions.

But they don’t take action.

This isn’t a knowledge gap or a solution gap—it’s an identity gap.

You may resonate with this because you’ve seen it in your own marketing. You may have felt the frustration of having an amazing solution that genuinely changes lives, yet you watch your prospects resist even when they admit they need it.

Today, we’re moving from understanding the problem to implementing the solution. No more guessing about what’s wrong. No more wondering why great solutions don’t sell.

The Science of How People Change

No more cut-and-paste marketing. No more pushing only to get pushback. Instead, let’s explore the science of how people change, and how to build your marketing around that reality.

What you’re about to learn will completely shift how you think about marketing. And it’s going to change how your prospects experience your marketing. Because when you get this right, you never have to convince people to buy your product again.

The Five Levels of Market Awareness

Here’s the reality that most marketers miss entirely:

Your market isn’t one homogeneous group of people waiting to hear about your solution. At any given moment, your market is split into five distinct groups, each requiring a completely different approach.

Understanding these levels of awareness changes everything about how you communicate. More importantly, it explains why most marketing fails. You might be saying the right thing, but you’re saying it at the wrong time.

Let’s break down each level:

1. Unaware

These people don’t even know they have the problem. 

They’re completely oblivious.

They wake up in the morning and they’re not thinking about the problem. They’re not looking at the problem. They’re not talking about the problem. They don’t even experience the physical, emotional, or literal symptoms of that problem.

2. Symptom Aware

These people wake up every morning feeling pain, but they don’t understand why. 

They know something’s wrong, they feel it viscerally, but they’re not sure what’s causing it.

They’re like someone who wakes up with back pain day after day— they feel the symptom, but they haven’t connected it to the root cause yet.

3. Problem Aware

At this level, they’ve diagnosed the issue. 

They know exactly what’s wrong.

They understand why they’re experiencing those symptoms. But—and this is crucial—they haven’t started seriously looking at solutions. They might even know solutions exist, but they’re not ready to act on them.

4. Solution Aware

These people know about various ways to solve their problems (including yours)…

But they haven’t chosen one yet.

They’re in that comparison phase, looking at different options, but something’s holding them back from making a decision.

5. Most Aware

This small segment knows about your solution specifically and just needs an offer to buy. 

They’re ready, willing, and able…

They just need you to present the right opportunity.

How to Know Where Your Prospects Are

This isn’t theoretical. Your prospects are telling you exactly where they are. But most marketers are too busy trying to sell to listen.

Here’s what to look for:

Unaware Prospects

They don’t even talk about the problem or anything related to it. They might even actively resist acknowledging it:

  • “Everything’s fine, I don’t need help with that”
  • “I don’t see why that would be an issue”
  • “That’s not something I think about”

Symptom Aware Prospects

They talk endlessly about how they feel and what’s happening, but they can’t name the root cause:

  • “I don’t know why this keeps happening”
  • “Something feels off but I can’t put my finger on it”
  • “I’ve tried everything but nothing seems to work”

Problem Aware Prospects

They can articulate exactly what’s wrong, but they push back on solutions:

  • “I know exactly why this is happening”
  • “I understand the problem, but…”
  • “I’ve looked into solutions, but I’m not sure…”

Solution Aware Prospects

They’re actively comparing options (and prices):

  • “What makes your approach different?”
  • “How does this compare to [competitor]?”
  • “I’ve tried X and Y, will this work better?”

Most Aware Prospects

They’re ready to buy and just need the right offer:

  • “When can we get started?”
  • “What’s the next step?”
  • “I just need to know the investment”

The Path Forward

Now that you understand the stages of awareness and how to identify where your prospects are, you can stop guessing (and stop pushing solutions on people who aren’t ready for them).

The key to creating marketing that works? Meeting your prospects where they are, speaking to them in a language they understand, and guiding them through these stages of awareness until they’re ready to buy.

This is what transformation looks like—no pushing, no convincing, no resistance.

Remember: Understanding these awareness levels isn’t just about categorizing your prospects. It’s about creating marketing that resonates at the right time, in the right way, with the right message. When you align your marketing with your prospect’s level of awareness, you transform your approach from manipulative to magnetic.

Topics:

Don’t Forget to Share

Related Articles

Cut-and-Paste Marketing Is Killing Your Business

Having a great solution isn’t enough when your prospects resist taking action. The problem isn’t your offer or how you explain it—it’s that your prospects haven’t become ready for change. Learn how to bridge the gap between knowing and doing by leading your audience through the transformation they need.

The 5-Step Framework for Turning Your Stories into Marketing Gold

Struggling to create consistent content? The goldmine of stories you need isn’t in some guru’s course—it’s in your everyday experiences. Transform your client interactions, challenges, and breakthroughs into powerful marketing content with the Story Journal™ framework. Learn how to mine your experiences for authentic stories that connect with your audience.

Loading...